Poor Herbie's  |  13  Waverly Place  |  Madison, NJ 07940  | Call for Reservation:  (973) 966-0211

To All Our Friends and Customers: Thank You

To all our loyal customers, friends, and neighbors:

On Tuesday, December 5, 2017, Poor Herbie's served its last beer, and its last burger. We thank you all from the bottom of our hearts for your loyal patronage over 25 years. We'll all be around and hope to see you in and around town in the months and years to come.

With warm thanks and best wishes for a Joyous Holiday Season 2017,

The Mullins Family

Facebook icon

Menu

We have a variety of Complete Entrees for your enjoyment,

served with crisp salad, crusty bread and either a baked Idaho or sweet potato, rice, mashed potatoes , vegetable, pasta, sweet or shoestring fries. Choose our famous House dressing or Thousand Island, honey mustard, oil & vinegar, or not-fat Italian.
Crumbled Bleu Cheese add $1.50

Happy Hour Menu

From 4:30pm to 6pm. Bar only

Wings $5.00

Five wings in our authentic Buffalo wing sauwce wih carrots, celery and our house bleu cheese dressing.

Buffalo Chicken Meatballs $5.00

Blue Cheese stuffed chicken meatballs with our wing sauce nd blue cheese dressing on the side.

Sampler $5.00

Three macaroni and chees triangles, three mozzarella stix, and three mini pierogies.

Kids' Menu

Franks in a Blanket $7.50
Mozzarella Stix $7.50
Grilled Cheese $7.50
Chicken Tenders/Fryz $7.50
Wings with choice of sauce $7.50
Mac 'n Cheese Triangles $7.50

Our Seasonal Appetizers

Steamed clams $8.95

18-20 count, served in a buttery clam sauce.

Shrimp Cocktail $9.95
Irish Ploughman's Platter $7.95

Thick chunks of cheddar cheese, whole grain bread, pickled red onions, pickles and a side of our Mullins mustard.

Breaded Calamari $8.25

Our Seasonal Entree Specials

Shrimp Creole $15.95

Stewed tomatoes, celery sauteed and served over linquine or rice.

Chicken Breast Parmigiana with linguine or rigatoni $18.95
Fish Special

Changes every week. Based on market price. Ask your server for details!

Bone-in Ribeye $23.95

This seasoned USDA choice cowboy steak is grilled to your liking and topped with sautéed mushrooms.

Tasty “Appe-teasers”

Guiness battered shrimp $8.95

Served with Boom Boom sauce and a Cucumber wasabi sauce. 

Soft Pretzels with Pub Cheese $8.95

Light and airy, served with our Bourbon St. Cheddar.

Stuffed Nachos $7.95

Filed with beef, pork and nacho cheese. 

Mac ’n Cheese Triangles $4.25
Chicken Fryz $6.95
“Flexible Flyers,” BBQ or Hot $7.50
Mozzarella Sticks $7.95
Den’s Hot Wings $9.75
Fried Pickles $4.25
Mini Pierogies "Your Way" $6.95
Cheddar Skins 'n Bacon $5.50

Homemade Salads & Platters

Crispy Iceberg Salad with our Famous House Dressing $5.50
Our White Tuna Salad Platter $11.95
Our Diced Chicken Breast Salad Platter $11.95
Famous Chef Salad w/ Turkey, Ham, Swiss, egg, bacon, tomatoes $14.95
Sliced Grilled Chicken Breast Salad with raw onion, bacon, tomatoes, egg $13.95
Grilled Sliced Steak Salad w/ Onion Tanglers, tomatoes $14.95

Sandwiches

Our Roast Turkey Breast & Gravy $11.95
Grilled Seasoned Chicken Breast $12.75
Our hot Roast Beef and Gravy $13.95
Classic Reuben $12.95
Our Tuna Melt $12.25
French Dip au jus $14.25
Sirloin Cheese Steak $13.95
Grilled American Cheese $7.95
Sizzlin' Hot Brooklyn Pastrami $13.25
Junior Turkey Club $11.95
Our White Tuna Salad $10.95
Our Savory Roast Beef $12.95
We-roast-it Turkey Breast $10.25
Our Diced Chicken Breast Salad $10.75

Wraps

We've taken our famous salads and turned them into wraps! Available at lunch only. 

Grilled Chicken Wrap $13.95

Chicken, lettuce, bacon, egg, tomato and onion with our  house dressing.

Grilled Steak Wrap $14.95

Steak, lettuce, onion tanglers and tomato with our house dressing.

Chef Salad $14.95

Ham, turkey, swiss cheese, egg, bacon, tomato and lettuce with our house dressing.

Diced chicken or tuna salad $11.95

Served with coleslaw, egg, and bacon.

Can’t Beat’em Burgers

Poor Herbie’s Classic $9.00
Bourbon St. Burger $11.00
Crumbled Bleu Cheese $11.00
Gluten Free Turkey Burger on Gluten Free Roll $8.50
Veggie-Burger on wheat $8.50
Burger Special

A different Burger every week. Ask your server for details and price.

Pasta Pleasures

Pasta with our chunky Homemade Marinara or smooth ‘Red’ Sauce $14.95
Pasta with Smooth Tomato Sauce $14.95
Pasta with Pink Blush Sauce $14.95
Baked Rigatoni with Mozzarella Cheese $14.95
Bleu cheese on your salad adds $1.50

Flame-Broiled On Our Grill

We have a variety of Complete Entrees for your enjoyment,

served with crisp salad, crusty bread and either a baked Idaho or sweet potato, rice, mashed potatoes , vegetable, pasta, sweet or shoestring fries. Choose our famous House dressing or Thousand Island, honey mustard, oil & vinegar, or not-fat Italian.

Crumbled Bleu Cheese add $1.50

12 oz. Center cut NY Strip Sirloin Steak, bone in $26.95
‘Poor Herbie’s’ Aged 18 oz. Ribeye ‘Club’ Steak $30.95
Rack of Lamb $23.95

7 Rib New Zealand Lamb sizzled on the grill with mint jelly.

Aged Angus 8 oz. Flatiron ‘Pub’ Steak $20.95

with sautéed onions & a cap of melted Mozzarella cheese

Savory Entrees

Roast 1/2 Chicken Golden or with our own BBQ Sauce $16.75
Our Premium Aged Steer Prime Rib au jus $29.95
Savory Pot Roast with mashed potatoes and gravy $17.95
Twin Succulent Baked Crab-Shrimp-Scallop-Cakes $18.95
Salmon Filet $18.95

Pan seared 8 oz. Scottish Salmon Filet

Our Shepherd’s Pie topped wth mashed potatoes $17.95
Crisp Half Roast Duck $18.95
Crispy Fried Chicken breast, leg, thigh and wing $16.95
Chicken Breast Francaise with lemon/butter sauce, on linguine or rice $19.95
Bangers & Mash $17.95

Traditional pork and beef Irish sausages topped with our onion stout demi-glaze. Served with peas and mashed potatoes.

Finishing Touches

Steamed Jasmine Rice* $1.95
Slivered Onion Tanglers $3.25
Today’s Steamed Veggies $2.50
Baked* or Mashed Potatoes $2.25
Hot Crusty Bread Loaf $3.25
Baked Sweet Potato* $2.95
Soup of the Day:
Cup $3.00
Bowl $5.00
Shoestring French Fries $2.75
Our Famous House Salad $5.50
w/ Crumbled Blue Cheese add $1.50
Steak-Cut Onion Rings $4.25
Sweet Potato Fries $3.95
Linguine/Rigatoni Marinara $5.95
Our Crunchy Homemade Cole Slaw $2.95

Beverages

Brewed Coffee, Regular or Decaf, with a refill $2.95
Caddy of Tea Selections: Regular, Herbal, Decaf, with a refill $2.95
Unsweetened Iced Tea, Lemonade, Fountain Sodas, with a refill $2.95
Orange, Tomato, Pineapple, Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit Juice $2.95
Mineral Water $3.95
Whole or Chocolate Milk $3.50
Hot Chocolate or Hot Cider $3.50